切换到宽版
  • 4231阅读
  • 10回复

[杏林风采]sci高手写的论文发表流程 [复制链接]

上一主题 下一主题
离线wypff18
 
发帖
2
啄木币
179
鲜花
7
只看楼主 倒序阅读 使用道具 0楼 发表于: 2006-10-22
sci高手写的论文发表流程

说明:这是一位有多篇外文sci在手的高手写的,主要是论文发表的一些流程,其中包含了与编辑通信的一些例子,很有借鉴意义,不敢独享,现全文转给大家

近几个月来,有三篇文章被SCI源期刊接受发表,虽然心里清楚自己的实际水平不咋地,但还是比较高兴的,总结一下过程供大家参考。说的不对的地方望大家拍砖。觉得有帮助的同学就顶一下。

首先,当然是要把文章写出来,这里要注意的是一定要写的规范、流畅、条理清晰,结果的好坏固然是最重要的,但一定要在意写作的水平。

下面是发表的过程
1.   上传或写信或发E-mail投递
Dear Prof. xxx(Editor):

Attached(写信就用Enclosed) please find the latex(或者PDF) version of my paper entitled "xxx" with the kind request to consider it for publication in the journal xxx.

The authors claim that none of the material in the paper has been published or is under consideration for publication elsewhere.

Should you receive the paper, please send me a e-mail to confirm receipt
of it.

Thanks a lot in advance!

Sincerely, yours

xxx
地址

稍加修改就可以作为一个上传时用的cover letter.
2.   收到中期决定
一般情况下,收到编辑部的来信,让作者根据审稿人的意见修改,并且在意见中看到审稿人推荐盖文章发表,就成功了一大半。以我收到的信为例:



Dear Mr. xxx,

Your manuscript, referenced above, has now been reviewed and the reviewer(s) have made suggestions which the Editor feels would improve your manuscript.

The Editor encourages you to consider these comments and make an appropriate revision of your manuscript. The reviewer(s)' comments are below.

Please submit your revision online within 4 weeks by logging onto the Elsevier Editorial System for the Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications:
http://ees.elsevier.com/xxx
The manuscript is now listed under "Submissions Needing Revisions." Click "Revise" when you are ready to submit your revision.

Please include a cover letter that addresses the issues raised in the below comments, point by point. You should also include a suitable rebuttal to any specific request for change that has not been made.

Thank you, and we look forward to receiving your revised manuscript.

With kind regards,

xxx
Associate Editor
3.   修改后再次上传
我修改后上传,coverletter如下:

Ms. No.: xxx
Title: xxx
Corresponding Author: xxx
Authors: xxx

Dear Editor:

My manuscript, referenced above, has been revised according to the reviewer(s)’comments.

I list the modifications as follows:

(1)...
(2)...
(3)...

We would like to thank the reviewer(s) for introducing the above literature to us. This is very helpful to our future study.

If there are other errors or further requests, please contact me by e-mail.

Sincerely, yours
xxx
地址
4.   收到最终决定
下面是我收到一例:

Ms. No.: xxx
Title: xxx
Corresponding Author: xxx
Authors: xxx

Dear Mr. xxx,

We are pleased to inform you that your manuscript referenced above has been accepted for publication in the Journal xxx.

Many thanks for submitting your fine paper to the xxx. We look forward to receiving additional papers from you in the future.

With kind regards,

xxx
Associate Editor
5.   收到版权转让声明以及抽印本订货单.
这封信比较长,不贴了,主要就是让你填好版权转让声明,因为已经赠送好多抽印本,所以不必再多订了,而且抽印本也是很贵的。接着要做的就是:
6.   填好版权转让声明、扫描后发送
信如下:
Our reference: xxx
Editorial reference: xxx
Title: xxx
To be published in: xxx

Dear xxx:

Attached please find the scanned copy of the signed TRANSFER OF COPYRIGHT
AGREEMENT of xxx. If there are other requests, please contact me by e-mail.  

I wonder when I can receive the proofs of xxx for correction.(问一句校样何时能收到)
Should you receive this letter, please send me an e-mail to confirm receipt of my signed TRANSFER OF COPYRIGHT AGREEMENT.

Many thanks in advance!

Sincerely, yours

xxx
地址
7.   收到校样及Author Query
8.   认真校对、认真填写Author Query后写信:
Dear Editor,

Thank you for your careful work. The proof of the article is wonderful.

But because of my carelessness, there are some inaccuracies in the proof of the article and I list them as follows. Please correct them before publication.

(1)...
(2)...
(3)...


In addition, attached please find the scanned Author Query Form which has been filled in carefully.

Should you receive this letter, please send me an e-mail to confirm receipt of it.

Many thanks in advance!

Kind regards,

xxx
地址
9.   耐心等待出版
10.   看到文章挂到网上,得意中
11.   还得继续写文章,痛苦并没有结束。。。 写好后重复第一条
12.   如此循环往复...
2条评分
linana 鲜花 +1 - 2006-10-22
xpxl 鲜花 +1 - 2006-10-22
评价一下你浏览此帖子的感受

精彩

感动

搞笑

开心

愤怒

无聊

灌水
离线merck
发帖
7064
啄木币
5576
鲜花
1074
只看该作者 1楼 发表于: 2006-10-23
大体过程是这样的。
不过cover letter写的太简单并不利。因为很多文章投给编辑,他们可能并不很熟悉你的研究方向,甚至专业,所以cover letter需要简要介绍一下自己科研的意义,使编辑能够了解你所做工作大体属于什么领域,什么审稿人审阅比较合适。如果送到外行审稿人手里,那么要么糊里糊涂被毙掉,要么提出一些啼笑皆非的审阅意见,对以后修改相当不利。有的杂志要求推荐审稿人,也是需要推荐与自己领域比较相关的专家为好。

关于稿件修改,退修意见一般要求point by point。稿件修回一定意义上是文章的再创作,要吸收退修意见的精华进行逐字逐句的修改,修改之处用红色在文中highlight一下。答复信的撰写非常有技巧,因为你可能并不能完全按照退修意见修改,只能进行部分修改。对于一些不合理的退修意见也无法照办。所以,需要不卑不亢的态度来答复,而且语气平和,客气。

退修信一般审稿人意见是分别给予的。要逐条分别答复,response to reviewer 1,response to reviewer 2...答复信开始要感谢editor的工作。答复每个审稿人意见一开始要感谢审稿人的辛勤工作,对于其文章的部分肯定要表示感谢和赞赏,对于地道的评价和建议要表示赞许。然后根据Question 1,Response 1;Question 2,response 2..进行逐条答复。注意,要提供参考文献等自己答复的引文的出处。对于审稿人不合理的要求,要因为该杂志已刊发文章进行驳斥,委婉说明此要求不合理,或者过度要求,或者表示此项研究会在以后进行,不补充此类试验已经足以证明自己的结论。对于修改之处,尽可能在response里面指出,配合文中的highlighted部分会给editor和reviewer非常好的感觉,作者进行了认真仔细的修改。

另外,国外大多数杂志投稿没有审稿费,很多杂志没有版面费(除彩照外)。
离线liu_redsnow
发帖
3119
啄木币
13806
鲜花
633
只看该作者 2楼 发表于: 2006-10-24
前一阵子药理请来的短期访问专家赵丰源讲座题目:
Publishing in SCI Journals

讲了他的SCI审稿经过

个人简介
Alex F. Chen, MD, PhD, FAHA
Departments of Pharmacology and Neurology
Cell and Molecular Biology Program
and Neuroscience Program
Michigan State University

ppt有十几兆
不方便附件
FTP最近似乎问题
等找时间拷过去
离线merck
发帖
7064
啄木币
5576
鲜花
1074
只看该作者 3楼 发表于: 2006-10-24
引用第2楼liu_redsnow2006-10-24 14:38发表的“”:前一阵子药理请来的短期访问专家赵丰源讲座题目:Publishing in SCI Journals讲了他的SCI审稿经过.......

陈丰源,不是赵。
他是asssistant professor
离线liu_redsnow
发帖
3119
啄木币
13806
鲜花
633
只看该作者 4楼 发表于: 2006-10-25
sorry
搞错了

看他的简历
发了不少SCI
好几篇IF都是十几
离线merck
发帖
7064
啄木币
5576
鲜花
1074
只看该作者 5楼 发表于: 2006-10-25
引用第4楼liu_redsnow2006-10-25 17:23发表的“”:sorry搞错了看他的简历发了不少SCI.......

有2篇circulation是主要的。
离线车驰

发帖
4860
啄木币
13466
鲜花
1539
只看该作者 6楼 发表于: 2006-10-25
SCI论文的写作与发表
附件: SCI论文的写作与发表.rar (19 K) 下载次数:51
1条评分
xpxl 鲜花 +1 - 2006-10-25
离线bluedoctor82
发帖
20
啄木币
201
鲜花
5
只看该作者 7楼 发表于: 2007-01-06
We are pleased to inform you that your manuscript referenced above has been accepted for publication in the Journal xxx
我最喜欢这句话了
离线xlpx
发帖
1232
啄木币
5021
鲜花
138
只看该作者 8楼 发表于: 2007-01-11
得好好研究研究
离线cambrian
发帖
237
啄木币
2
鲜花
106
只看该作者 9楼 发表于: 2007-04-26
好啊,支持一下
离线大葱蘸酱
发帖
637
啄木币
192
鲜花
113
只看该作者 10楼 发表于: 2007-04-26
好东西一定要顶!!
快速回复
限100 字节
 
上一个 下一个